Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joseph Mapes | 1729 | Southold | Farmer |
| James Mapes | 1746 | Southold | Farmer |
| Joseph Jr. Mapes | 1755 | Southold | Farmer |
| Israel Mapes | 1762 | Southold | Farmer |
| Thomas Mapes | 1735 | Southold | Cordwainer |
| Joseph Marshall | 1734 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Ebenezer Marthers | 1730 | Southold | Carpenter |
| Jedediah Marvin | 1748 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Moses Marvin | 1756 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| John Marvin | 1728 | Brookhaven | Cordwainer |
| Timothy Mathers | 1719 | Southampton | Weaver |
| Joseph Mathews | 1733 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| James McCluer | 1727 | Southold | Merchant |
| James McCluer | 1759 | Southold | Farmer |
| John McCown | 1728 | Huntingdon | Carpenter |
| David McFarthing | 1731 | Southold | Shipwright |
| Nathaniel Miger | 1763 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Timothy Miller | 1722 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Robert Miller | 1755 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Andrew Miller | 1726 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Timothy Miller | 1762 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Ebenezer Miller | 1737 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Timothy Miller | 1722 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Nathaniel Miller | 1755 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Andrew Miller | 1726 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Timothy Jr. Miller | 1762 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Ebenezer Miller | 1737 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Uriah Miller | 1750 | Southampton | Blacksmith |
| David Miller | 1757 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Ananias Miller | 1738 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Ananias Miller | 1738 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Timothy Miller | 1744 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Nathan Miller | 1745 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Joseph Miller | 1745 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| David Miller | 1749 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| John Miller | 1707 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Jeremiah Jr. Miller | 1749 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Hunting Miller | 1754 | Easthampton | Miller |
| Ezekiel Miller | 1756 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Uriah Miller | 1721 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| William Miller | 1739 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Abraham Miller | 1762 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Joel Miller | 1760 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| George Miller | 1730 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Daniel Miller | 1763 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Lewis Miller | 1763 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Benjamin Miller | 1751 | Easthampton | Shoemaker |
| Matthew Miller | 1735 | Easthampton | Shoemaker |
| Elisha Miller | 1751 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Zophar Mills | 1741 | Brookhaven | Farmer |