Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Andrew Mills | 1754 | Brookhaven | Hatter |
| Jonathan Mills | 1710 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Jonas Mills | 1715 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Jonas Jr. Mills | 1753 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Timothy Mills | 1750 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Wickham Mills | 1757 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| William Mills | 1760 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Jedediah Mills | 1756 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Ebenezer Mills | 1759 | Smithtown | Weaver |
| Samuel Mills | 1753 | Smithtown | Weaver |
| Jacob Mills | 1724 | Smithtown | Weaver |
| Isaac Mills | 1726 | Smithtown | Weaver |
| Micah Mills | 1743 | Smithtown | Joiner |
| Jonathan Mills | 1761 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Charles Mitchel | 1756 | Southold | Doctor |
| David Mode | 1741 | Southampton | Miller |
| Christian Moger | 1728 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Isaiah Moger | 1747 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Daniel Moger | 1761 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Auther Moger | 1751 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Goreat Monfort | 1751 | Huntingdon | Weaver |
| Gerret Montford | 1751 | Islip | Weaver |
| Henry Moore | 1750 | Southampton | Cordwainer |
| Benjamin Moore | 1743 | Southold | Farmer |
| John Moore | 1760 | Southold | Farmer |
| Daniel Moore | 1763 | Southold | Farmer |
| Henry Moore | 1720 | Southold | Farmer |
| Benjamin Moore | 1761 | Southold | Farmer |
| Jonathan Moore | 1760 | Southold | Farmer |
| Zadoc Moore | 1752 | Southold | Farmer |
| John Moore | 1731 | Southold | Farmer |
| Simon Moore | 1717 | Southold | Joiner |
| Silas Moore | 1715 | Southold | Farmer |
| Thomas Jr. Moore | 1756 | Southold | Farmer |
| Thomas Moore | 1733 | Southold | Farmer |
| Henry Jr. Moore | 1754 | Southold | Cordwainer |
| John Moore | 1758 | Southold | Cordwainer |
| John Morgan | 1744 | Huntingdon | Taylor (tailor) |
| James Morris | 1741 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| James Morris | 1740 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| William Morris | 1748 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| William Morris | 1748 | Islip | Farmer |
| Joseph Mott | 1750 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Jacob Mott | 1763 | Huntingdon | Cordwainer |
| Joseph Mott | 1724 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Thomas Mount | 1746 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Anning Mowbray | 1751 | Islip | Farmer |
| John Mowbray | 1720 | Islip | Farmer |
| John Mowbray | 1720 | Islip | Farmer |
| Anning Mowbray | 1751 | Islip | Farmer |