Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Daniel Osborne | 1713 | Southold | Farmer |
| Jacob Osborne | 1746 | Southold | Farmer |
| Isaac Overton | 1740 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| James Overton | 1746 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Nehemiah Overton | 1759 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Palmer Overton | 1749 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| David Overton | 1737 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Justis Overton | 1756 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Benjamin Overton | 1753 | Brookhaven | Weaver |
| David Overton | 1715 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Messenger Overton | 1755 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Thomas Overton | 1740 | Southold | Farmer |
| James Overton | 1751 | Southold | Blacksmith |
| John Jr. Overton | 1735 | Southold | Farmer |
| Joshua Overton | 1745 | Southold | Cordwainer |
| Nathaniel Jr. Overton | 1752 | Southold | Weaver |
| Moses Overton | 1752 | Southold | Weaver |
| Isaac Overton | 1763 | Southold | Farmer |
| Nathaniel Overton | 1711 | Southold | Miller |
| John Overton | 1706 | Southold | Farmer |
| Stephen Overton | 1762 | Southold | Farmer |
| Abijah Owen | 1753 | Southold | Farmer |
| Micah Owen | 1761 | Southold | Farmer |
| James Owen | 1721 | Southold | Farmer |
| James Pain | 1744 | Smithtown | Hatter |
| Benjamin Pain | 1744 | Southold | Shoemaker |
| Rufus Pain | 1756 | Southold | Shoemaker |
| John Pain | 1740 | Southold | Cooper |
| John Pain | 1758 | Southold | Farmer |
| John Pain | 1761 | Southold | Farmer |
| Benjamin Pain | 1751 | Southold | Husbandman |
| John Jr. Pain | 1763 | Southold | Joiner |
| Elnathan Paine | 1728 | Southampton | Shoemaker |
| John Paine | 1737 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Paul Paine | 1750 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Jonathan Paine | 1704 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Daniel Paine | 1712 | Southampton | Farmer |
| James Paine | 1744 | Smithtown | Hatter |
| Thomas Paine | 1761 | Southold | Farmer |
| Moses Paine | 1760 | Southold | Farmer |
| Cyrus Panderson | 1778 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| William Parker | 1753 | Southold | Cooper |
| Abraham Parker | 1722 | Southold | Ferryman |
| Joseph Parker | 1761 | Southold | Farmer |
| Phineas Parker | 1749 | Southold | Farmer |
| Elias Parshall | 1748 | Southold | Mariner |
| Abraham Parsons | 1756 | Southampton | Weaver |
| Lemuel Jr. Parsons | 1744 | Southampton | Weaver |
| Ludham Parsons | 1747 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| John Parsons | 1745 | Easthampton | Farmer |