Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whitehead Saxton | 1755 | Huntingdon | Carpenter |
| Caleb Saxton | 1750 | Huntingdon | Blacksmith |
| James Saxton | 1759 | Huntingdon | Carpenter |
| Ezekiel Sayre | 1733 | Southampton | Mariner |
| Nehemiah Sayre | 1701 | Southampton | Blacksmith |
| Ichabod Sayre | 1699 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Stephen Sayre | 1751 | Southampton | Weaver |
| Abraham Sayre | 1744 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Matthew Sayre | 1732 | Southampton | Cordwainer |
| Joseph Sayre | 1704 | Southampton | Farmer |
| James Sayre | 1753 | Southampton | Blacksmith |
| Silas Scallenger | 1740 | Southampton | Lawyer |
| Jonathan Scallenger | 1733 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Abraham Schellenger | 1740 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Jacob Schellenger | 1759 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Jonathan Schillenger | 1762 | Easthampton | Shoemaker |
| Samuel Scidmore | 1722 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Jackson Jr. Scott | 1757 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Jackson Scott | 1718 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Samuel Scott | 1759 | Southampton | Farmer |
| John Scott | 1762 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Seth Scribner | 1744 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Joseph Scribner | 1747 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Joseph Scribner | 1718 | Brookhaven | Cordwainer |
| Nathaniel Scrivener | 1761 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Jonah Scudder | 1744 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Jonathan Scudder | 1736 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Thomas Scudder | 1725 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Moses Scudder | 1761 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Jacob Scudder | 1763 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| David Sears | 1752 | Southampton | Weaver |
| Abraham Sears | 1748 | Southampton | Joiner |
| Job Sears | 1760 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Benjamin Sears | 1711 | Southampton | Blacksmith |
| Ichabod Jr. Sears | 1730 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Isaac Sears | 1757 | Southampton | Shoemaker |
| John Sears | 1722 | Southampton | Shoemaker |
| Joshua Sears | 1728 | Southampton | Farmer |
| James Sell | 1743 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Westle Sell | 1746 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| James Sell | 1743 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| James II Sell | 1756 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Westle Sell? | 1746 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| John Sells | 1755 | Huntingdon | Cordwainer |
| Abner Seward | 1763 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Joseph Seward | 1716 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Caleb Sexton | 1750 | Islip | Blacksmith |
| Daniel Shaw | 1742 | Southold | Cordwainer |
| Jacob Sheniel | 1723 | Easthampton | Joiner |
| Recompence Sherrel | 1708 | Easthampton | Farmer |