Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Charles Smith | 1756 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Nicholas Smith | 1762 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| John Smith | 1763 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Isaac Smith | 1761 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| William Jr. Smith | 1744 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Job Jr. Smith | 1748 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Ebenezer Smith | 1749 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Joseph Smith | 1715 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| William Smith | 1709 | Islip | Farmer |
| Mowbray Jr. Smith | 1759 | Islip | Farmer |
| Mowbray Smith | 1735 | Islip | Miller |
| Isaac Smith | 1761 | Islip | Farmer |
| Thomas Smith | 1750 | Islip | Farmer |
| William Jr. Smith | 1737 | Islip | Farmer |
| Platt Smith | 1746 | Islip | Farmer |
| James Smith | 1748 | Islip | Farmer |
| Silas Smith | 1739 | Islip | Farmer |
| Platt Smith | 1746 | Islip | Farmer |
| Mowbray Smith | 1735 | Islip | Miller |
| James Smith | 1749 | Islip | Farmer |
| Joseph Sneedecat | 1753 | Huntingdon | Joiner |
| John Sooper | 1748 | Huntingdon | Cooper |
| Benjamin Soper | 1756 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Jeremiah Soper | 1756 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Jacob Soper | 1761 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| William Soper | 1718 | Huntingdon | Carpenter |
| Lemuel Soper | 1745 | Smithtown | Farmer |
| Moses Sopher | 1745 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Benjamin Spicer | 1728 | Southampton | Gardiner |
| Ellis Squire | 1739 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Jonathan Squire | 1736 | Easthampton | Cordwainer |
| John Squire | 1739 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Abraham Squires | 1729 | Southampton | Weaver |
| John Squires | 1740 | Huntingdon | Mariner |
| Abraham St. John | 1755 | Southampton | Taylor (tailor) |
| David Stamborough | 1742 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Stephen Stamborough | 1747 | Southampton | Weaver |
| Lewis Stambrough | 1738 | Southampton | Silversmith |
| James Stanbrough | 1750 | Southampton | Weaver |
| Nathan Stephens | 1751 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Thomas Jr. Stephens | 1733 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Thomas Stephens | 1706 | Southampton | Farmer |
| William Stephens | 1743 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Edward Stephens | 1754 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Silas Steward | 1744 | Southampton | Mariner |
| William Still | 1753 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Peter Still | 1762 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| David Stillwell | 1755 | Huntingdon | Cordwainer |
| Jeremiah Stratton | 1719 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Daniel Stratton | 1754 | Southampton | Farmer |