Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gilbert Case | 1748 | Southold | Farmer |
| James Case | 1749 | Southold | Weaver |
| John Case | 1751 | Southold | Joiner |
| Benjamin Celark | 1731 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Henry Chadewayne | 1728 | Smithtown | Labourer |
| Francis Chateling | 1726 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Henry Chatfield | 1750 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| John Chatfield | 1716 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Abraham Cherry | 1750 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Pine Chichester | 1759 | Huntingdon | Blacksmith |
| Epraim Chichester | 1763 | Huntingdon | Cooper |
| Eliphalet Chichester | 1738 | Huntingdon | Carpenter |
| Sylvanus Chichester | 1738 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Henry Chichester | 1763 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Samuel Chichester | 1751 | Huntingdon | Cordwainer |
| Elijah Chichester | 1744 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Ichonas Chick | 1728 | Huntingdon | Farmer |
| Benjamin Chose | 1726 | Southampton | Carpenter |
| Ludlow Clark | 1742 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| William Clark | 1709 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Samuel Clark | 1711 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Nathan Clark | 1722 | Southampton | Cordwainer |
| Nathan Jr. Clark | 1762 | Southampton | Farmer |
| John Clark | 1740 | Southold | Weaver |
| Joshua Clark | 1721 | Southold | Farmer |
| John Clark | 1718 | Southold | Weaver |
| Barnabus Clarke | 1743 | Southampton | Farmer |
| Joseph Clarke | 1738 | Southampton | Physician |
| Beriah Cleaves | 1737 | Southold | Farmer |
| David Cleaves | 1733 | Southold | Weaver |
| Ichabod Cleveland | 1740 | Southold | Carpenter |
| Joseph Cleveland | 1760 | Southold | Cooper |
| Joseph Cleveland | 1727 | Southold | Cooper |
| Joshua Cleves | 1730 | Southold | Cordwainer |
| Benjamin Colman | 1737 | Southampton | Blacksmith |
| Joel Conkling | 1755 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Zephaniah Conkling | 1749 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Jacob Conkling | 1733 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Isaac Conkling | 1745 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Jeremiah Conkling | 1749 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Nathan Conkling | 1736 | Easthampton | Taylor (tailor) |
| Jeremiah Conkling | 1749 | Easthampton | Cooper |
| Elias Conkling | 1704 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Zebulon Conkling | 1733 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Edward Conkling | 1731 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Daniel Conkling | 1737 | Easthampton | Cordwainer |
| David Conkling | 1762 | Easthampton | Shoemaker |
| Samuel Conkling | 1747 | Easthampton | Farmer |
| Mulford Conkling | 1757 | Easthampton | Weaver |
| Cyncas Conkling | 1718 | Easthampton | Farmer |