Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jacob Burger | Staten Island | ||
| Tobias Burke | Staten Island | ||
| George Burnes | Staten Island | ||
| Garret Bush | Staten Island | ||
| Nicholas Bush | Staten Island | ||
| Edward Bush | Staten Island | ||
| Thomas Butler | Staten Island | ||
| Henry Butler | Staten Island | ||
| Daniel Butler | Staten Island | ||
| James Butler | Staten Island | ||
| John Butler | Staten Island | ||
| David Cannon | Staten Island | ||
| David Jr. Cannon | Staten Island | ||
| Jacob Cannon | Staten Island | ||
| Isaac Cannon | Staten Island | ||
| Hendrick Carrager | Staten Island | ||
| Dowes Carson | Staten Island | ||
| Frank Cazelous | Staten Island | ||
| Cornelius Christopher | Staten Island | ||
| Joseph Christopher | Staten Island | ||
| Edmon Christopher | Staten Island | ||
| Richard Christopher | Staten Island | ||
| John Clandening | Staten Island | ||
| John Cochran | Staten Island | ||
| Abraham Cockeron | Staten Island | ||
| Abraham Cockren | Staten Island | ||
| Stephen Cole | Staten Island | ||
| Jacob Cole | Staten Island | ||
| Cornelius Cole | Staten Island | ||
| Isaac Cole | Staten Island | ||
| Benjamin Cole | Staten Island | ||
| Jonas Colon | Staten Island | ||
| Ismes Colon | Staten Island | ||
| Peter Colon | Staten Island | ||
| Richard Conner | Staten Island | ||
| Jacob Cook | Staten Island | ||
| Richard Corbey | Staten Island | ||
| Daniel Corsen | Staten Island | ||
| Donald Corsen | Staten Island | ||
| Daniel Corsen | Staten Island | ||
| Richard Corsen | Staten Island | ||
| Cornelius Corson | Staten Island | ||
| Peter Cortelyou | Staten Island | ||
| Aaron Cortelyou | Staten Island | ||
| Cornelius Cortelyou | Staten Island | ||
| Garret Cosin | Staten Island | ||
| Wilhelmas Cozine | Staten Island | ||
| Jacobus Cozine | Staten Island | ||
| William Crips | Staten Island | ||
| Richard Crips | Staten Island |