Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Isaac Mills | |||
| Obadiah Mills | |||
| Amos Mills | |||
| Nathaniel Mills | |||
| Samuel Mills | |||
| Nathaniel Mills | |||
| Nathaniel Jr. Mills | |||
| Jonas Mills | Smithtown | ||
| Nathaniel Mills | |||
| Joshua Mills | |||
| Obadiah Mills | |||
| Hope Mills | |||
| Samuel Millson | |||
| John Milner | |||
| Lewis Miltenbergh | Cordwainer | ||
| Peter Minenbilt | New Utrecht | ||
| Mangle Minthorne | Storekeeper | ||
| John Minuse | Yeoman | ||
| John Minuss | |||
| Jacob Misheroll | Bushwick | ||
| Abram Misheroll | Bushwick | ||
| Charles Mitchel | 1756 | Southold | Doctor |
| John Mitchel | |||
| Viner Mitchell | |||
| James Mitchell | |||
| Viner Mitchell | |||
| Viner Mitchell | Labourer | ||
| Henry Mitchell | Watchmaker | ||
| James Mitchell | Mason | ||
| Andrew Mitchell | Merchant | ||
| John Jr. Mitchell | |||
| Augustine Mitchell | |||
| John Jr. Mitchell | |||
| Robert Mitchell | |||
| John Mitchell | |||
| Lewis Mitchell | Staten Island | ||
| Lewis Mitchell | Staten Island | ||
| William Mo[...]? | |||
| Daniel Moas | |||
| David Mode | 1741 | Southampton | Miller |
| William Moer | Carpenter | ||
| John Moffit | Merchant | ||
| John Moffite | Gentleman | ||
| Christian Moger | 1728 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Isaiah Moger | 1747 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Daniel Moger | 1761 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Auther Moger | 1751 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Isaiah Moger? | |||
| Peter Molenear | Bushwick | ||
| William Molenear | Bushwick |