Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| John Peters | |||
| Henry Peters | Merchant | ||
| Bemsley Peters | Planter | ||
| Valentinett Peters | |||
| John Peters | |||
| Valentine Peters | Esquire | ||
| Valentine Peters | Queens | Esquire | |
| Paulus Peterson | Labourer | ||
| Nicholas Peterson | Labourer | ||
| Abraham Peterson | Boatman | ||
| David Peterson | Labourer | ||
| Jacob Peterson | |||
| David Peterson | |||
| Samuel Pettelin | |||
| Samuel Pettet | |||
| P. Pettett | |||
| Benjamin Pettey | |||
| John Pettinger? | Shipwright | ||
| James Pettit | |||
| William Pettit | |||
| John Pettit | |||
| John Pettit | |||
| Obadiah Pettit | |||
| William Pettit | |||
| Benjamin Pettit | |||
| John Pettit | |||
| Samuel Pettit | |||
| James Jr. Pettit | |||
| Adam Pettit | |||
| William Pettit | |||
| Joseph Pettit | |||
| Incrase Pettit | |||
| Michael Pettit | |||
| Samuel Pettit | |||
| Isaac Pettit | |||
| Isaac Pettitt | |||
| Increase Pettitt | |||
| Joseph Jr. Pettitt | |||
| James Petty | |||
| Nathaniel Petty | |||
| John Petty | |||
| William Petty | |||
| Daniel Petty | |||
| Daniel Petty | 1745 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| James Petty | 1750 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Benjamin Petty | 1756 | Brookhaven | Carpenter |
| James Petty | 1752 | Brookhaven | Farmer |
| Joseph Petty | 1726 | Southold | Farmer |
| Joseph Jr. Petty | 1763 | Southold | Farmer |
| James Petty | 1742 | Southold | Farmer |