Loyalists
| Name | Birth Year | Residence | Occupation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whited Sexton | |||
| Thomas Sexton | Sailmaker | ||
| Caleb Sexton | 1750 | Islip | Blacksmith |
| John Seyson | |||
| Michael Shadel | Carman (cartman) | ||
| Daniel Shadin | |||
| Benjamin Shadwell | Labourer | ||
| Jacob Shafer | |||
| Jacob Shafer | Scrivener | ||
| William Shally | Gunsmith | ||
| John Shamler | Gardener | ||
| Daniel Shan | |||
| James Shank | Shipwright | ||
| William Shardiwine | Brooklin (Brooklyn) | ||
| Evert Shareman | Flatbush | ||
| Jacob Sharp | Brooklin (Brooklyn) | ||
| Jacob Jr. Sharp | Brooklin (Brooklyn) | ||
| Richard Sharpe | Merchant | ||
| Richard Sharwin | |||
| John Shaver | Tobacconist | ||
| John Shaver | Yeoman | ||
| John Shaver | Labourer | ||
| Charles Shaw | |||
| George Shaw | |||
| James Shaw | |||
| George Shaw | |||
| John Shaw | |||
| Charles Shaw | Merchant | ||
| John Shaw | Merchant | ||
| David Shaw | Merchant | ||
| John Shaw | Jeweller | ||
| James Shaw | Venduemaster | ||
| George Shaw | Tanner | ||
| Daniel Shaw | 1742 | Southold | Cordwainer |
| Samuel Shaw | |||
| Henry Shaw | |||
| Henry Shaw | |||
| Amos Shaw | |||
| Harmon Shaw | |||
| Gilbert Sheall | Farmer | ||
| Valentine Sheamell | Labourer | ||
| Lewis Shear | Farmer | ||
| John Sheffer | Yeoman | ||
| Daniel Sheir | Tobacconist | ||
| George Shell | Pilot | ||
| Christopher Shell | Carman (cartman) | ||
| Jacob Shell | Baker | ||
| Jacob Sheniel | 1723 | Easthampton | Joiner |
| Edward Sheppard | Perukemaker | ||
| John Sheppard | Mason |